Skip across the chapter
Quota Playbook

Form I-9 timing: 3 checks for a new seller

Quota Playbook Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read

Section 1 is due at hire and section 2 within three business days, unless the job lasts fewer than three business days.

Key takeaways

The regulation sets three distinct timing points for Form I-9 completion.

  • First, the employee completes section 1, titled “Employee Information and Verification,” at the time of hire, signing the attestation with a handwritten or electronic signature as required by the rule, according to Legal Information Institute.
  • Second, the employer completes section 2, titled “Employer Review and Verification,” within three business days of the hire, also signing the attestation with a handwritten or electronic signature, according to Legal Information Institute.
  • Third, if the employment duration is less than three business days, the employer must comply with both section 1 and section 2 requirements at the time of the hire, according to Legal Information Institute.

These timing rules operate separately from national-origin discrimination protections. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects employees or applicants from discrimination based on national origin, including Americans, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. This protection does not alter the three-day clock for section 2 or the at-hire requirement for short-term jobs. The national-origin rule addresses bias in hiring and treatment, not the deadline for completing verification paperwork.

Complete section 1 at hire and section 2 within three business days

The first timing check for a new seller is section 1, which the employee completes at the time of hire. This section is titled “Employee Information and Verification.” The employee signs the attestation with a handwritten or electronic signature, according to Legal Information Institute. If the individual is unable to complete the form or needs it translated, someone may assist him or her, according to Legal Information Institute. This part of the form belongs to the employee and happens on the first day.

The second timing check is section 2, which the employer completes within three business days of the hire. This section is titled “Employer Review and Verification.” The employer signs the attestation with a handwritten signature or electronic signature, according to Legal Information Institute. The three-business-day window starts when the hire occurs. You do not have to wait until the end of the week to finish this part if the seller starts on a Monday. If that start day moves, check sales rep schedule changes.

Write the date the seller starts work in your notes. This date anchors both timing checks. Section 1 happens on that date. Section 2 happens within three business days after that date. Keep the two dates separate in your records. The employee’s signature in section 1 and the employer’s signature in section 2 are distinct actions. One does not replace the other.

If the seller is remote, the same timing rules apply. Section 1 is still at the time of hire. Section 2 is still within three business days of the hire. The physical location of the seller does not change the deadline. You can use an electronic signature for either section, according to Legal Information Institute. The regulation allows handwritten or electronic signatures for section 1, and handwritten or electronic signatures for section 2. A remote hire can still rehearse with remote software demo rehearsal.

Do not confuse the three-business-day clock with other hiring deadlines. This specific window applies to the completion of section 2 on Form I-9. It is not a general onboarding deadline for all paperwork. It is a specific requirement for the employer’s review and verification part of the form.

The three timing checks: section 1, section 2, and a job under three days

The standard rule requires the new seller to complete section 1 at the time of hire, while the employer completes section 2 within three business days of the start date. This two-step process applies to most permanent sales roles. However, a specific exception exists for short-term engagements. If you hire a seller for employment lasting less than three business days, the timing rules change immediately. According to Legal Information Institute, an employer who hires an individual for employment for a duration of less than three business days must comply with paragraphs (b)(1)(ii)(A) and (b)(1)(ii)(B) of this section at the time of the hire. This means both section 1 and section 2 are due at the exact moment of hire for these short jobs. You cannot wait three days to finish the paperwork if the engagement ends sooner.

When handling a job that lasts fewer than three business days, you must verify the documents immediately. The standard allowance for a substitute paper does not apply here. According to Legal Information Institute, an employer may not accept a substitute paper, as described in paragraph (b)(1)(vi) of this section, in lieu of the required document if the employment is for less than three business days. If a seller presents a substitute paper for a document they are waiting to receive, you must decline it for a short-term role.

To apply this correctly, check the expected duration of the seller’s role before starting the form. If the role is a standard permanent position, section 1 is due at hire and section 2 is due within three business days. If the role is a short-term project or temporary assignment lasting less than three business days, both sections are due at hire. In that short-term scenario, do not accept a substitute paper in lieu of the required document, and complete both sections at the time of hire. Write the date of hire on section 1 and complete section 2 with the verified documents on that same day. This ensures the form is fully compliant at the start of the engagement.

Illustrative example: one longer hire and one short job

A seller is hired for a role that continues past three business days. Section 1 is completed at the time of hire. Section 2 is completed within three business days of the hire, and the employer signs then. A second seller is hired for employment lasting less than three business days. Both section 1 and section 2 are completed at the time of the hire. A substitute paper is not accepted in lieu of the required document. Keeping a copy of the document does not replace a completed section 2.

Copies, substitute papers, and the three-day inspection notice

A common source of confusion for new managers is the difference between retaining a document and completing the form. Under the rules for 8 CFR § 274a.2 - Verification of identity and employment authorization, the copying or electronic imaging of any such document and retention of the copy or electronic image does not relieve the employer from the requirement to fully complete section 2 of the Form I-9, according to Legal Information Institute. This means that scanning a seller's driver's license or passport and saving it to a shared drive does not finish the paperwork. You must still physically or electronically fill out the certification block in section 2. The copy serves as a record of the document presented, but it does not replace the employer's attestation that the document reasonably appears genuine.

It is also important to distinguish the hiring clock from the inspection notice. The three business days mentioned in the hiring timeline refer to the deadline for completing section 2 after the employee starts work. However, there is a separate "three-day" rule that applies to government inspections. Any person or entity required to retain Forms I-9 in accordance with this section shall be provided with at least three business days notice prior to an inspection of Forms I-9 by officers of an authorized agency of the United States, according to Legal Information Institute. This notice period is a right granted to the employer to prepare for a review by an authorized agency. It is not a deadline for you to finish the form. If you are managing the hiring process, you do not wait for an inspection notice to complete section 2. You complete section 2 within three business days of the start date as part of your standard onboarding workflow.

What the statute says a genuine document and a paperwork penalty mean

The U.S. Code Title 8, "ALIENS AND NATIONALITY," defines the standard for examining documents. A person or entity complies with the requirement for examining a document if the document reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, according to U.S. Government Publishing Office. This test focuses on the document's appearance rather than its ultimate validity. You do not need to verify the document's authenticity beyond this reasonable appearance standard. The rule applies to the specific paragraph regarding document examination. It is not a promise that every document presented is valid, but it sets the compliance line for the employer's review.

When a violation occurs regarding the paperwork requirements, the statute specifies a civil penalty range. For a violation of the relevant subsection, the order requires the person or entity to pay a civil penalty of not less than $100 and not more than $1,000 for each individual with respect to whom the violation occurred, according to U.S. Government Publishing Office. This range applies specifically to violations of the paperwork paragraph. It is a statutory range, not a fixed fine for your specific firm. The penalty is assessed for each individual affected by the violation.

The statute also addresses the employment relationship after the initial hire. It is unlawful for a person or other entity, after hiring an alien for employment in accordance with the first paragraph, to continue to employ the alien in the United States knowing the alien is (or has become) an unauthorized alien with respect to such employment, according to U.S. Government Publishing Office. This is a separate ban on continuing to employ a person the employer knows is unauthorized. It distinguishes the initial paperwork compliance from the ongoing obligation regarding known unauthorized status.

For your new seller, apply the "reasonably appears genuine" test when reviewing their documents. Do not accept a document simply because it was offered; check if it reasonably appears genuine on its face. If you are unsure whether a document meets this appearance standard, consult your legal counsel before completing the form. Keep the penalty range in mind as a baseline for the seriousness of paperwork errors, but do not predict the exact amount for your team. The law provides a range. Focus on meeting the appearance standard to stay compliant with the examination requirement.

Filled reference table of I-9 rules by publisher

The table below lists the specific I-9 timing and document rules stated in the regulation text. Each row identifies the publisher and the rule stated in the source text.

Publisher Rule Source Quote
Legal Information Institute Section 2 must be completed within three business days of hire. "(B) Complete section 2—“Employer Review and Verification”—on the Form I-9 within three business days of the hire and sign the attestation with a handwritten signature or electronic signature in accordance with paragraph (i) of this section."
Legal Information Institute If employment lasts less than three business days, both sections are due at hire. "(iii) An employer who hires an individual for employment for a duration of less than three business days must comply with paragraphs (b)(1)(ii)(A) and (b)(1)(ii)(B) of this section at the time of the hire."
Legal Information Institute Section 1 is completed by the employee at the time of hire. "(A) Completes section 1—“Employee Information and Verification”—on the Form I-9 at the time of hire and signs the attestation with a handwritten or electronic signature in accordance with paragraph (h) of this section; or if an individual is unable to complete the Form I-9 or needs it translated, someone may assist him or her."
Legal Information Institute A substitute paper cannot be accepted in lieu of a document for short-term employment. An employer may not accept a substitute paper, as described in paragraph (b)(1)(vi) of this section, in lieu of the required document if the employment is for less than three business days.
Legal Information Institute Employers must receive at least three business days' notice before an agency inspection. "(ii) Any person or entity required to retain Forms I-9 in accordance with this section shall be provided with at least three business days notice prior to an inspection of Forms I-9 by officers of an authorized agency of the United States."
Legal Information Institute Retaining a copy of a document does not replace the requirement to complete section 2. "The copying or electronic imaging of any such document and retention of the copy or electronic image does not relieve the employer from the requirement to fully complete section 2 of the Form I-9."

How the hire date anchors section 1 and section 2

The regulation requires the employee to complete section 1, titled "Employee Information and Verification," at the time of hire according to Legal Information Institute. The employer must then complete section 2, titled "Employer Review and Verification," within three business days of the hire according to Legal Information Institute. If the job lasts fewer than three business days, the regulation requires both sections to be completed at the time of hire according to Legal Information Institute. In that case, the section 2 due date is the same as the section 1 date. The employee may sign the attestation with a handwritten or electronic signature according to Legal Information Institute. Keep this note with the signed Form I-9 for your records.

Action step: Verify that your onboarding checklist includes a specific line item for "Section 2 certification complete," distinct from "Documents scanned and saved." This ensures that the completion of the form is tracked separately from the retention of the document copies. Then set the first coaching talk using a reminder check before the next coaching talk.

Form I-9 timing FAQ

When is section 1 due?

Section 1, titled “Employee Information and Verification,” is completed at the time of hire, according to Legal Information Institute. The employee signs the attestation with a handwritten or electronic signature, and someone may assist if the individual is unable to complete the form or needs it translated, according to Legal Information Institute.

When is section 2 due?

Section 2, titled “Employer Review and Verification,” is completed within three business days of the hire, according to Legal Information Institute.

What changes if the job lasts fewer than three business days?

If employment is for a duration of less than three business days, the employer must comply with both section 1 and section 2 at the time of the hire, according to Legal Information Institute. The three-business-day window for section 2 does not apply in this case, according to Legal Information Institute.

Can I accept a substitute paper for a short job?

An employer may not accept a substitute paper in lieu of the required document if the employment is for less than three business days, according to Legal Information Institute. The required document must be presented and verified at the time of hire for these short-term positions, according to Legal Information Institute.

Sources

  1. Track 8 lead filter checks for stalled deal reviews
  2. Sales record reassignment: 5 checks before rep exits
  3. Pipeline stages: 8 checks and a 5 to 7 range
  4. New-seller onboarding time: track it with 3 milestone parts
  5. Check the 28-day backup line before a practice reset

More plays