Skip across the chapter
Quota Playbook

Tiered commission plan: 4 steps for a 1:1 talk

Quota Playbook Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read

To explain a tiered commission plan in a 1:1, cover the tier table, one worked deal, any bonus, and when commission is earned.

Key takeaways

  • Walk the seller through the tier table before any worked deal.
  • Run one closed deal through the bands and read out the rate used.
  • Show bonuses and product rates on separate lines from the tiers.
  • State when commission is earned in the wording of your written plan.
  • Keep the worked example on file after the talk.

Show the bands before tying any number to a real deal, and keep the bonus on its own line.

Why the plan walkthrough belongs in a 1:1

A one-on-one gives room for the question a group meeting rarely handles, which is what a specific deal pays. A plan can read clearly on a slide and still confuse a seller when a real deal lands near a band boundary. Use the time to slow down on that boundary and answer the follow-up questions the seller brings. Bring the plan document, one real deal and a blank page for notes. For the wider meeting structure, see the sales one-on-one agenda.

Front-line managers often explain a plan from memory, which makes small differences easy to miss. Write the bands on paper before the meeting, and check each boundary against the written plan. The seller should leave with the same version you hold. If the copies differ, pause the conversation until the team agrees which version governs. Keep the discussion on the rules themselves, not on any single seller's results.

A useful opening line tells the seller what the meeting covers and what it leaves out. Say that the tiers describe the base rate, that bonuses come after, and that the worked deal is a teaching example. The aim is to keep the seller from treating every number on the page as a promise. That framing also gives you a clean way back to the plan when a question drifts off topic.

Spend more of the meeting on examples than on definitions, because questions about boundaries come up there. Pick one example that falls near a band edge so the boundary is visible. Ask the seller to explain the same deal back in their own words before the meeting ends.

Use the same words for bands, bonuses and earnings throughout the talk. If you say band in one sentence and tier in the next, the seller may hear different rules. Agree on one term for each idea before you start the worked deal. Write those terms at the top of the tier table so both of you can point to them.

Step 1: put the tier table on the page

Start the meeting with the tier table in front of the seller, not in a follow-up email. Reps earn 5% commission on deals up to $50,000, 7% on deals between $50,001 and $100,000, and 10% for anything above $100,000, according to Captivateiq. Copy those bands into your table, then replace the figures with your team's own limits.

Label each band with its rate and its exact limits on the same line. Show the first band as up to $50,000, then the middle band as $50,001 to $100,000, so no deal size falls between lines. Ask the seller to read one band aloud before you move on. Then ask whether any band needs a clearer boundary. Use the same wording as your written plan so the seller can match each line.

Check the table against the plan document before the meeting. Confirm that each band names a rate, a lower limit and an upper limit where your plan has one. If a boundary is missing from your plan, fix the plan first. Do not invent a band to fill a gap on the page.

A tier table with no source line invites the question of where the rates came from. Add a short label above the table that says these are the team's rates. Name the date the plan takes effect only if the written plan states it. Store the table with the plan so both match.

Give the seller their own copy of the table before the talk ends. A printed or shared page gives the seller a reference that does not depend on memory. Ask the seller to mark the band that matches their current deal size. Move to the next step once the marked band and the written plan agree.

Step 2: work one deal through the tiers

Choose one closed deal from your own records and leave the customer's name off the page. Start with the deal size, since the example bands are set by deal size. Find the matching band before you name a rate. Say the rate out loud as a full sentence that includes the band name.

A deal between $50,001 and $100,000 falls in the middle band, so the rate is 7%, according to Captivateiq. Ask the seller which of their own bands the same deal size would fall into. Then compare the answer with the table you wrote.

Confirm with your written plan whether the 10% top rate applies to the full deal or to the part above the limit. Your plan may answer that question differently from the example. Put the top band last so the seller reads the bands in order from smallest deal to largest. Write the answer on the table in plain words so every seller reads the same rule.

Walk the worked deal once from start to finish, saying each step out loud. Note any step the seller struggles to repeat, because that step needs a clearer line on the page. Pause after the rate and ask one question about the band before you add any bonus.

Do not move on while the seller is still unsure which band applies. Mark the example as an illustration in your written notes so it is not read as a rate card.

Illustrative example: a deal in the first band

This deal is made up and is not a rate from your team. A deal of $1,000 sits in the first band, so the 5% rate from Step 1 applies. Say the band, then say the rate in one full sentence, before you move on to bonuses.

Step 3: explain bonuses and product rates

Explain bonuses after the base tiers, not in the middle of them. If the company wants to incentivize upselling premium features, it can add a bonus, for instance a $500 payout for each customer who upgrades to a premium plan, according to Captivateiq. Keep its trigger in plain words so the seller can check each trigger.

The commission automation software described by Captivateiq can assign varying rates, such as 10% for high-margin items and 5% for accessories, or implement tiered plans where rates increase with sales volume, according to Captivateiq. Show product rates on their own lines so the seller can see which rate applies to which item. If your plan uses product rates, ask the seller to name the item before stating the rate.

Write the bonus as an added amount on its own line, not as a change to the tier rate. Test the wording by asking whether the bonus would still read clearly if the tier rates changed. Give the seller the bonus rule in writing before the first deal that could trigger it.

Use one customer in the example to show how the bonus is triggered. Name the trigger, the payout and the plan the customer moved to. Leave out any upgrade you have not checked. If the upgrade happened in a different month from the deal, say so, so the seller does not blend the bonus into the commission.

Close this step by checking that every bonus and product rate has a source line in your written plan. Mark any line that has no matching sentence in the plan for review. Recheck the bonus and rate lines after any change to the plan.

Step 4: say when commission is earned

Say when commission is earned before you discuss how much it is. A rep closes a $120,000 annual deal with a 10% commission in one example, according to Performio. Put that example on the page with the date the deal closed so the seller can track it. State the earning point in the same words your written plan uses. Ask the seller which event in your plan marks the earning point.

The plan pays commission monthly as revenue is recognized, meaning $1,000 should be earned and accrued each month, according to Performio. Read that line as the example's own rule, not as a rule for your team. If your written plan pays monthly, show each monthly amount on its own line. Do not assume a monthly amount matches a fixed share of the deal unless your plan says so. Put each monthly amount beside the date it is earned.

Keep the earning point separate from the payment date in your explanation. Name each one in the written plan, using the same words in both places. Read the earning sentence aloud in the meeting, once before the example and once after it. If the points differ for any deal type, write that difference down as its own line.

Check the earning rule against a deal that closes near the end of a month, since that deal shows where the earning point falls. Write down the answer your plan gives, not the answer the seller expects. Keep that answer on the page beside the tier table. Confirm the answer with whoever owns the written plan before the next 1:1.

If the seller can repeat it without help, move on to the record. If not, return to the deal example. Keep the note short and factual, with the question written in the seller's own words. Close the meeting with a time for the next question.

What to keep on file after the talk

Keep the worked example on file

Keep one record for each plan you explain. Put the tier table, the worked deal and the bonus line on the same page, with the date the talk took place. Store that page where you and the seller can both find it. For exit records, see the final commission record guide. Use a plain title that names the seller's role and the plan being explained. Label the version number on the page so later changes can be told apart from the original wording.

When a seller moves to a new role, the record should show which version of the plan was explained to that seller, and which version applies after the move. Plans can be cloned and adjusted in minutes as roles change, according to Captivateiq. Do not overwrite the earlier record; keep it in the same folder and label it as superseded. Check the new record with the seller before the change takes effect.

Record the bonus trigger in the same wording the seller heard in the meeting. Note the customer or deal the bonus applied to, and the rule that made it apply. If a bonus was paid or not paid, mark the reason in one sentence so a later question can be answered from the file. For a later dispute, see the HubSpot audit log for a commission dispute: 7 steps. Keep product rates on the same page, beside the bonus lines for each deal.

The table below lists the quoted wording from the tier and $120,000 deal sources used in this guide.

Publisher Quoted wording Page
Captivateiq Reps earn 5% commission on deals up to $50,000, 7% on deals between $50,001 and $100,000, and 10% for anything above $100,000. Commission automation software explainer
Performio For example, a rep closes a $120,000 annual deal with a 10% commission. Accrued commission errors article

Compare the worked example with the first real deal that closes under the plan. Note any band or bonus the example did not cover, and add a line for it. Use the seller's own words for the case, not a label from this guide. Check whether the written plan already answers that case before you ask the seller to decide. Bring the note to the next 1:1.

Write a short note of what the seller asked and what you answered, kept to a few sentences. Include the band, the bonus trigger and the earning point the seller confirmed. Mark any answer you still need to check with the written plan. Store the note with the record so both sit together. Confirm the note matches the record before you close the file.

Your next step is to pick one recent closed deal and run it through your seller's plan in the next 1:1.

FAQ

How do tiered commission rates work?

Under a tiered plan, the rate changes at each deal-size limit, as the Captivateiq example shows. Read the bands in your own written plan to see which rate applies to a deal near a limit. Ask whoever maintains the plan how a deal that straddles a limit is paid.

Can a bonus sit on top of the commission?

Yes, a bonus can be added on top of the base tiers. Name the trigger in the written plan before the first upgrade question comes up.

When is commission earned on an annual deal?

In the sourced example, commission on the annual deal is earned monthly as revenue is recognized.

How should the plan be shown to the seller?

Show the table as a page the seller can keep, with each band, rate and limit on its own line. Walk one worked deal through it, then add the bonus line and the earning point. Mark the page as an illustration if any figure is only an example.

Can rates vary by product?

Yes, a plan can assign different rates to different items, according to Captivateiq. Check whether your written plan splits rates by item before you quote any figure. Store the item list with the table so the split can be checked.

Can a plan change when a role changes?

Yes, a plan can change when a role changes, so the file has to show which version applies. Ask the seller to confirm which version their current role uses. Date each version so the file shows which one was in force on each date.

Sources

  1. Weekly pipeline review: 3 standing checks to run
  2. Pump break numbers: 3 figures to read before comparing
  3. Response-time lines: 4 published figures to check
  4. Erase a departing rep's Mac

More plays