Skip across the chapter
Quota Playbook

Commission deduction mistakes: 4 errors to catch

Quota Playbook Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read

Flag four commission deduction errors before payroll: negligence charges, oral withholding agreements, overtime wage cuts and deductions kept after an employee is found not guilty. Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes notes an employer cannot deduct from an employee's wages loss to employer from burglaries, robberies or alleged negligent act.

Key takeaways

Commission deduction mistakes: 4 errors to catch

When a proposed deduction appears on a commission check, verify the underlying basis against the specific statutory language cited for your state. The first error to flag is charging a rep for alleged negligence. Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes states that an employer cannot deduct from an employee's wages loss to the employer from burglaries, robberies or alleged negligent act. If the proposed deduction cites alleged negligence as the reason, flag it immediately.

The second error involves using an oral withholding agreement. Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes identifies an oral agreement to withhold, deduct or divert any portion of an employee's wages as illegal. The source notes a 100% penalty plus interest is approved for this violation. If the deduction relies on a verbal conversation, flag the proposal.

The third error is reducing overtime wages during the calculation phase. North Carolina General Assembly specifies that no reductions may be made to overtime wages owed. If the proposed deduction lowers the total amount of overtime pay the rep is entitled to receive, flag it. This restriction applies specifically to the overtime component of the compensation, distinguishing it from other potential adjustments to base pay or commission structures that might be permissible under different circumstances.

The fourth error is keeping a deduction after an employee is found not guilty. North Carolina General Assembly provides that if the employee is not found guilty, the amount deducted shall be reimbursed to the employee by the employer. Flag any proposal that keeps the withheld amount.

Verify the specific state statute before approving any payroll change. Do not apply one jurisdiction's rule to another. Keep each restriction tied to its named source.

Before approval: flag negligence charges and oral agreements

Flag the proposed deduction if it relies on a charge of alleged negligence or rests on an oral agreement to withhold pay. Under the rules identified by the Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes, an employer cannot deduct from an employee's wages any loss to the employer resulting from burglaries, robberies, or an alleged negligent act ( Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes). If the payroll proposal cites a rep's alleged negligence as the reason for reducing their commission, mark that line for review before approval. The annotation for section 44-319 identifies this prohibited deduction, so verify that the underlying event does not fall into the excluded categories of burglary, robbery, or alleged negligence.

Separately, check whether the deduction is based on an oral withholding agreement. The Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes states that an oral agreement to withhold, deduct, or divert any portion of an employee's wages is illegal ( Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes). If the deduction stems from a verbal understanding, flag it immediately. The presence of an oral agreement triggers the illegality described in this annotation, so verify any withholding basis against the statute itself before processing the payroll run.

Distinguish these prohibitions from compensation structures that remain permissible. The Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes notes that a combination of commission and hourly wage plans, when consistent with the employment agreement between the parties, is not violative of the statute ( Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes). Do not confuse a valid mixed compensation structure with an illegal deduction for negligence or an oral withholding agreement. If the rep's pay is split between commission and hourly wages, confirm that the deduction does not violate the specific prohibitions on negligence losses or oral agreements.

Use the table below to compare the specific restrictions and their statutory citations.

Restriction Type Statutory Citation Key Rule Publisher
Negligence Charges 44-319 Employer cannot deduct loss from burglaries, robberies or alleged negligent act Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes
Oral Withholding 44-315 Oral agreement to withhold wages is illegal; 100% penalty plus interest approved Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes
Mixed Compensation 44-319 Combination of commission/hourly wage plan consistent with employment agreement not violative Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes

During calculation: protect overtime and distinguish other hours

When payroll calculates a proposed commission deduction, the manager must verify whether the rep's hours fall into a nonovertime workweek or an overtime workweek. The North Carolina General Assembly distinguishes these two scenarios in G.S. 95-25.8. In a nonovertime workweek, an employer may reduce wages to the minimum wage level. This permission applies specifically to the first scenario where no overtime hours were worked during that period.

The calculation changes when the workweek includes overtime. In overtime workweeks, employers may reduce wages to the minimum wage level for nonovertime hours. This means the deduction can affect the straight-time portion of the pay, but the calculation must stop before touching the premium pay. The statute explicitly separates the nonovertime hours within that week from the overtime wages themselves.

The most critical restriction for the sales manager is the protection of the premium pay. No reductions may be made to overtime wages owed. If the payroll system attempts to apply the deduction to the overtime portion, the manager must flag the error immediately. The rule prohibits any reduction to the overtime wages that are owed to the employee. This protection remains in place regardless of the other wage adjustments permitted in the same workweek.

Workweek Type Statutory Citation Deduction Permission Publisher
Nonovertime Workweeks G.S. 95-25.8 (1) Employer may reduce wages to the minimum wage level North Carolina General Assembly
Overtime Workweeks (Nonovertime Hours) G.S. 95-25.8 (2) Employers may reduce wages to the minimum wage level for nonovertime hours North Carolina General Assembly
Overtime Wages Owed G.S. 95-25.8 (3) No reductions may be made to overtime wages owed North Carolina General Assembly

Review the time records to identify which hours are nonovertime and which are overtime. Apply the deduction only to the nonovertime hours if the workweek is an overtime workweek. Ensure the overtime wages remain untouched in the final calculation. For more on overtime errors, see overtime errors for non-exempt sales reps.

After the underlying case: check reimbursement and recovery routes

When a criminal case concludes with a finding that the employee is not guilty, the employer must handle the previously withheld funds. You should verify the final court outcome before processing any further payroll adjustments. For the payroll handoff, see sales rep final pay checks. If the verdict is not guilty, the payroll system must reverse the deduction and return the full withheld amount to the rep's account. Do not retain these funds pending internal review once the legal finding is final. The obligation to reimburse is direct and tied to the specific judicial result.

The statute also clarifies the employer's separate legal options for recovering legitimate debts. G.S. 95-25.8 states that nothing in the Article precludes an employer from bringing a civil action in the General Court of Justice to collect any amounts due the employer from the employee. This provision preserves a distinct civil recovery route that operates independently of the criminal deduction mechanism. It allows the employer to pursue unpaid amounts through the court system if the employee owes money for reasons unrelated to the criminal charge or if the criminal route does not cover the full debt. This civil action is a separate legal process from the payroll deduction. You should not assume that a criminal conviction or acquittal resolves all financial disputes between the employer and the employee. The civil route remains available for collecting amounts due.

State deduction reference table and supporting payroll records

Payroll records document what was paid and deducted; they do not authorize the deduction itself. The table below lists specific record items and one trustee provision from the named sources. Each row is traceable to its publisher's quote.

Record/Provision Item Statutory Citation Requirement or Description Publisher
Employee Identity WAC 296-128-010 (1) Name in full, and identifying symbol or number if used on time, work, or payroll records Washington State Legislature
Workweek Start WAC 296-128-010 (5) Time of day and day of week on which the employee's workweek begins Washington State Legislature
Pay Period Deductions WAC 296-128-010 (9) Total additions to or deductions from wages paid each pay period Washington State Legislature
Trustee Status Section 4113.15 (C) Employer becomes trustee of funds for authorized deductions in absence of contest, court order or dispute Ohio Laws and Administration

These recordkeeping rules define what must be documented, not whether a deduction is legally permitted. The Washington State Legislature allows employers to use symbols where names or figures are called for, provided the symbols are uniform and defined. If a workforce or establishment has all workers beginning their workweek at the same time on the same day, a single notation of the time and beginning day for the whole group will suffice under this rule.

The Ohio Laws and Administration describes a different type of provision. Under Section 4113.15 (C), an employer who is party to an agreement to pay fringe benefits or make employee-authorized deductions becomes a trustee of those funds from the time the duty to pay arises. This trustee status applies in the absence of a contest, court order, or dispute. This provision does not grant general permission to deduct commissions; it defines the employer's fiduciary role regarding funds already authorized by agreement.

Distinguish between the record of a deduction and the legal basis for it. A payroll entry showing a commission deduction satisfies Washington's recordkeeping requirement for pay period totals but does not validate the deduction under Kansas or North Carolina restrictions. Before approving any deduction, verify the substantive legal basis in the applicable state's evidence, separate from the administrative record. Use the table above to confirm your payroll records capture the required identity, workweek, and deduction totals, then check the substantive restrictions discussed in the earlier sections of this guide. Today, pull the commission deduction lines from your next payroll draft and check each one against the four errors above.

FAQ: proposed deductions from a seller's commission

What commission deduction mistakes should I flag?

Flag four specific errors before payroll approval. These include charging for alleged negligence, using oral withholding agreements, reducing overtime wages, and keeping deductions after an employee is found not guilty. Verify each item against the specific state’s statutory evidence.

Can an employer deduct wages for alleged negligence in Kansas?

The Kansas Office of Revisor of Statutes notes that an employer cannot deduct from wages loss to the employer from burglaries, robberies or alleged negligent acts. This restriction applies specifically to the jurisdiction named in the source. Do not apply this rule to other states without separate verification.

Can North Carolina employers reduce overtime wages owed?

The North Carolina General Assembly prohibits reductions to overtime wages owed. This rule distinguishes nonovertime workweeks from nonovertime hours within overtime workweeks. Any proposed deduction that lowers the overtime compensation owed violates this specific provision.

What payroll deduction records does Washington list?

The Washington State Legislature lists employee identification, the workweek start and pay-period additions or deductions as payroll record items. Specifically, total additions to or deductions from wages paid each pay period must be recorded. These recordkeeping requirements do not authorize the deductions themselves.

Does the Ohio trustee provision cover disputed deductions?

The Ohio Laws and Administration provision applies in the absence of a contest, court order or dispute. It describes trustee status for funds covered by specified benefit or employee-authorized deduction agreements. This provision does not grant general permission to deduct commissions in all circumstances.

Sources

  1. Seller login removal: 4 data clocks to check first
  2. Sales paycheck deductions: 4 steps for pay talks
  3. Pay a departing rep's commission in 3 steps (Minnesota)
  4. Wage deduction authorization
  5. HubSpot audit log for a commission dispute: 7 steps

More plays