Skip across the chapter
Quota Playbook

Sales paycheck deductions: 4 steps for pay talks

Quota Playbook Editorial Team · Published · 12 min read

Start by separating Social Security and Medicare deductions, then explain the authority for other deductions and route unresolved wage differences to payroll, using the IRS rate structure as your baseline. According to Internal Revenue Service, taxes under FICA are composed of Social Security and Medicare taxes.

Start by separating Social Security and Medicare deductions

When a rep asks why their commission check is lighter than expected, the first move is to separate the two federal payroll tax components. The IRS defines the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) as being composed of the old-age, survivors, and disability insurance taxes (Social Security) and the hospital insurance taxes (Medicare), according to Internal Revenue Service. That single definition gives you the cleanest opening line: there are two federal taxes, not one lump deduction.

State the employee share plainly. The current tax rate for Social Security is 6.2% for the employer and 6.2% for the employee, or 12.4% total, according to Internal Revenue Service. The current rate for Medicare is 1.45% for the employer and 1.45% for the employee, or 2.9% total, according to Internal Revenue Service. Point to the employee column and show that the rep's own 6.2% and 1.45% match those lines.

The employer share is not an additional deduction from the rep's wages. When a rep sees a line for Social Security or Medicare, they are looking at their own 6.2% and 1.45%. The employer's matching amounts are a cost to the company, not a subtraction from the rep's pay. Say that distinction out loud: "Your paycheck shows your share. The company pays a matching share on top of that, but it never comes out of your check."

Keep the explanation to the two taxes and their rates. Do not move into income tax withholding, state taxes, or benefits premiums in this first step. Show the rep the employee rate of 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare on wages subject to each tax, noting that Social Security withholding stops once wages hit that year's wage base while all covered wages stay subject to Medicare. Once the rep accepts that the Social Security and Medicare lines are standard, the next question becomes which other deductions have authority behind them.

Explain the wage base that limits Social Security withholding

Once you've separated Social Security from Medicare, the next question a rep will ask is why the Social Security line stopped growing after a certain amount. That's the wage base, and you can explain it in one sentence: according to Internal Revenue Service, the wage base limit is the maximum wage that's subject to the tax for that year. The rep's Social Security withholding stops once their year-to-date wages hit that limit.

You don't need to memorize the dollar figure, because the IRS points you to a specific place for it. According to Internal Revenue Service, refer to "What's New" in Publication 15 for the current wage limit for Social Security wages. That's the reference to give the rep and the one to check before you promise a number in a pay discussion.

The contrast with Medicare matters for the explanation. According to Internal Revenue Service, all covered wages are subject to Medicare tax. So even after the Social Security wage base is reached, the Medicare line keeps appearing on every paycheck for the rest of the year. That's why a rep's paycheck can look different in December than it did in March: the Social Security deduction stops at the wage base, and Medicare continues.

Use this framing in the pay talk: the wage base is a ceiling on the wages subject to Social Security tax, and the IRS publishes the current limit in Publication 15's "What's New" section. Medicare has no such ceiling for covered wages. If the rep wants the exact current number, point them to that IRS publication rather than quoting a figure from memory.

Identify the authority for each New Hampshire deduction

For employees governed by New Hampshire law, name the authority behind a deduction line on the check. New Hampshire's withholding statute sorts deductions into separate categories, and each category has its own test.

Start with this category: deductions the employer is required or empowered to make by state or federal law, including payroll taxes, according to New Hampshire General Court. That is the authority for the tax lines on the check, and it is the easiest one to explain because the employer is not choosing to take the money.

The second category is voluntary contributions into cafeteria plans or flexible benefit plans, or both, as authorized by section 125 or section 132 of the Internal Revenue Code, according to New Hampshire General Court. If the rep elected a benefit plan contribution, the authority is the plan election plus the Internal Revenue Code sections the state statute names.

The third category is the one that needs the most care in a pay discussion: a deduction for any purpose on which the employer and employee mutually agree that does not grant financial advantage to the employer, when the employee has given written authorization and deductions are duly recorded, according to New Hampshire General Court. Three conditions sit inside that sentence. There must be mutual agreement, the agreement must not grant financial advantage to the employer, and the employee must have given written authorization with the deductions duly recorded. If the rep says they never signed anything, that is the category to check first, because the written authorization is part of the rule.

The fourth category covers medical care. Deductions are allowed when they are pursuant to any rules or regulations for medical, surgical, or hospital care or service, without financial benefit to the employer and openly, clearly, and in due course recorded in the employer's books, according to New Hampshire General Court. The recording requirement appears here too, so the employer's books should show the deduction.

There is also a restriction worth knowing before the conversation starts. The withholding shall not be used to offset payments intended for purchasing items required in the performance of the employee's job in the ordinary course of the operation of the business, according to New Hampshire General Court. If a deduction looks like it is paying for a required job item, it does not fit the mutual-agreement category.

For the pay talk, walk the rep through the check line by line and assign each deduction to one of these categories. Tax lines go to the state or federal law category. Benefit plan contributions go to the cafeteria plan category. Under New Hampshire employment, a mutual-agreement line needs written authorization, a recorded entry, and no financial advantage to the employer, while a medical line follows medical rules, no financial benefit to the employer, and a recording in the employer's books.

When a deduction does not fit any category, do not try to explain it away. Take that line to payroll and ask which authority supports it before the rep leaves the conversation.

Route unresolved differences using the applicable state's provisions

When a rep's paycheck still doesn't add up after you've separated the tax components and checked the deduction authority, the next step is to route the dispute using the wage provisions of the state where the rep works. These provisions are jurisdiction-specific, so keep them tied to the named state rather than treating them as a national rule.

For a rep in Wisconsin, the state defines a wage deficiency as the difference between the amount required by law to be paid and the amount actually paid. According to Wisconsin State Legislature, "Wage deficiency" means the difference between the amount required by law to be paid and the amount actually paid to an employee. Use this definition to frame the conversation: if the rep's paycheck shows less than the amount the law required the employer to pay, the difference is a wage deficiency under this statute. That gives you a concrete label for the gap the rep is seeing, rather than a vague sense that something is off.

For a rep in Minnesota, the wage-claim provisions work differently and carry two points worth stating plainly in the pay discussion. According to Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes, money collected by the commissioner must be paid to the employee concerned. Money collected by the commissioner must be paid to the employee concerned. Second, the provision does not shut the door on the employee's own action. According to Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes, this section does not prevent an employee from prosecuting a claim for wages. So the rep retains the ability to pursue a wage claim even where the commissioner's collection process exists.

End the conversation with one clear action: tell the rep you will take the disputed line items to payroll and ask them to confirm which deductions carry documented authority under the applicable state provision before the next pay period.

Publisher reference table for the rep's pay discussion

When a rep asks where a deduction comes from, the fastest way to keep the conversation grounded is to point to the authority behind each line. The table below pulls together the four sources that matter most for the pay talk, with the exact provision each one establishes.

Publisher Key provision Source quote
Internal Revenue Service Social Security tax shares "The current tax rate for Social Security is 6.2% for the employer and 6.2% for the employee, or 12.4% total."
New Hampshire General Court Written mutual deduction authorization "(12) For any purpose on which the employer and employee mutually agree that does not grant financial advantage to the employer, when the employee has given his or her written authorization and deductions are duly recorded."
Wisconsin State Legislature Defining a wage deficiency "109.01(4)(4) 'Wage deficiency' means the difference between the amount required by law to be paid and the amount actually paid to an employee."
Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes Payment of collected money "Money collected by the commissioner must be paid to the employee concerned."

Each row names the publisher that owns the rule, so when a rep asks "who says that's allowed?" you can answer with the source rather than with your own reading of the paystub. The IRS row anchors the tax side, the New Hampshire row covers the authorization requirement, and the Wisconsin and Minnesota rows give you the language for unresolved differences. Keep this table in front of you during the conversation and you will not have to guess at which authority backs which line.

Use the table as a routing tool: limit the IRS row to the Social Security and Medicare shares shown there, and for New Hampshire employment assign payroll taxes required or empowered by state or federal law to that legal-authority category; use the New Hampshire row only for a mutual-agreement deduction governed by New Hampshire law; use the Wisconsin wage-deficiency wording only for a rep in Wisconsin; and use the Minnesota commissioner sentences only for a rep in Minnesota.

Keep the deduction authorization and recorded deduction evidence

When New Hampshire law governs a mutual-agreement deduction, the conversation turns on this New Hampshire provision: the deduction is allowed "[f]or any purpose on which the employer and employee mutually agree that does not grant financial advantage to the employer, when the employee has given his or her written authorization and deductions are duly recorded," according to New Hampshire General Court. That single sentence gives you the three things to check before you defend the line item to the rep.

First, confirm the agreement was mutual. The provision covers a purpose "on which the employer and employee mutually agree," so a deduction the rep never accepted does not fit this category under the cited statute. Second, confirm the authorization was written—the provision requires "written authorization," not a verbal okay or a silent acceptance of a past paycheck. Third, confirm the deduction was recorded. The same provision requires that deductions "are duly recorded."

Use those three checks as the script for the pay talk. Ask payroll to pull the written authorization and the recorded deduction entry before you meet with the rep. Before you tell the rep the deduction matches the statute, confirm mutual agreement, written authorization, a recorded entry, and that the agreement does not grant financial advantage to the employer. If any element is missing, the deduction does not meet the mutual-agreement category as written, and the next step is to route the unresolved difference to payroll rather than defend it yourself.

FAQ: explaining deductions on a sales rep's paycheck

How do I explain sales paycheck deductions?

Start by separating Social Security and Medicare deductions, then explain the authority for other deductions. According to Internal Revenue Service, the current tax rate for Social Security is 6.2% for the employer and 6.2% for the employee, or 12.4% total. For other deductions, point to the specific authority that permits them, such as New Hampshire's mutual-agreement category, which applies when the employee has given written authorization and deductions are duly recorded, according to New Hampshire General Court.

What employee and employer tax shares does the IRS list?

Social Security is 6.2% each and Medicare is 1.45% each, according to the IRS.

Does the New Hampshire mutual-agreement deduction provision cover an agreement without written authorization?

No; the provision requires the employee's written authorization. According to New Hampshire General Court, the mutual-agreement category applies when the employee has given his or her written authorization and deductions are duly recorded.

Which IRS publication gives the current Social Security wage limit?

Publication 15, in the IRS "What's New" section.

What does Wisconsin mean by a wage deficiency?

The difference between the amount required by law to be paid and the amount actually paid.

Sources

  1. USERRA return clocks: 4 deadlines before return
  2. Fix 8 lead source gaps before your coaching session
  3. Check the 50-field cap before a coaching activity log
  4. Protected classes pay discrimination managers
  5. HubSpot audit log for a commission dispute

More plays