Washington defines protected classes to include age (40 and older), sex, race and disability, according to Washington State Department of Labor and Industries. A person may bring a claim based on more than one protected class, according to Washington State Legislature. Those points are the starting place for any note about why one seller earns more than another.
Key takeaways: four facts
Each sourced point below carries its publisher, so the wording can be checked against the source before a pay conversation.
- Washington's protected class list includes age (40 and older), sex, race and disability, among others, according to Washington State Department of Labor and Industries.
- a person may assert discrimination based on membership in more than one protected class, according to Washington State Legislature.
- Title VII makes it illegal to discriminate based on sex in pay and benefits, according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
- a good-faith differential tied to a local government ordinance providing for a minimum wage different from state law does not constitute discrimination under this section, according to Washington State Legislature.
- keep a written, job-based reason for each seller pay difference, and check that reason against the Washington list before any pay conversation.
The fifth bullet is an editorial recommendation rather than wording from any source, so the job-based reason should be written in the manager's own words.
Why protected classes matter when you set pay
If a seller asks why a colleague earns more, the answer should hold up against the rules as well as against habit. The Washington wording looks at comparisons between employees. According to Washington State Legislature, any employer in this state who discriminates in any way in providing compensation based on a person's gender or membership in a protected class between similarly employed employees of the employer is guilty of a misdemeanor.
Two scope words in that sentence matter for your notes. The comparison is between similarly employed employees, and the test concerns membership in a protected class. On a small team, the group of similarly employed sellers may be small, so writing down the comparison group is a concrete first step before any figure is discussed.
The same statute also addresses the employee's position. According to Washington State Legislature, if any employee receives less compensation because of discrimination on account of the person's gender or membership in a protected class in violation of this section, that employee is entitled to the remedies in RCW 49.58.060 and 49.58.070.
The wording is a useful starting point for your own notes, and questions about your company's obligations belong with the people who advise it on employment law.
Washington's list of protected classes
In Washington's Equal Pay & Opportunities Act, according to Washington State Department of Labor and Industries, protected classes are defined as: age (40 and older), sex, marital status, sexual orientation, race, creed, color, national origin, citizenship or immigration status, honorably discharged veteran or military status, or the presence of any sensory, mental, or physical disability or the use of a trained dog guide or service animal by a person with a disability.
The list describes Washington. A team in another state needs that state's list, and the people who advise your company can confirm which list applies to your team.
A practical use of the list is a checklist. Each seller's pay difference goes beside the classes on the list, and the job-based reason goes next to it. If a class on the list is involved and the reason does not name the job, the note needs more work before the next conversation. For a related topic, see accommodation requests for managers.
A useful habit is to keep each note short, dated and specific to one seller. A long note that covers several sellers at once makes it harder to see which reason belongs to which person. Reading the full list in the source, rather than a summary, helps a manager catch classes that a short memory of the list would miss. The list shows which categories to check, and it does not settle a pay question on its own. For a log format, see sales coaching logs.
Claims based on more than one class
The statute speaks about one person and more than one class, which matters for how notes are kept. According to Washington State Legislature, a person may file a complaint or bring an action under this chapter asserting discrimination based on the person's membership in more than one protected class.
Keeping the seller, the comparison group and the job-based reason in one record puts the facts for one person in one place. A useful test for each entry is whether the reason names the job rather than a protected class that applies to the seller.
When two classes seem to apply to one seller, write the job-based reason once and check it against each class on the list. That way each class is checked against the same job-based reason.
A single-seller entry can follow the same order every time: the comparison group, the classes checked, and then the job-based reason. Using one order across every entry makes the notes easier to compare side by side during a pay review.
Federal overlap: Equal Pay Act and Title VII
The EEOC page connects the Equal Pay Act to Title VII. According to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, someone who has an Equal Pay Act claim may also have a claim under Title VII.
The same page lists the protected bases. According to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Title VII, the ADEA, and the ADA prohibit compensation discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, or disability.
The two lists overlap. According to Washington State Department of Labor and Industries, the Washington list includes race, color, sex, national origin, age (40 and older) and disability. According to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the federal text names those same classes and also religion.
Religion is the difference to watch. According to Washington State Department of Labor and Industries, the Washington list includes creed, and according to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the federal text names religion, so a note that covers federal bases should check religion separately. Because the two sets overlap, a note that states the job-based reason clearly is useful under either source. It is worth writing once rather than twice, and then checking it against both lists where they apply to your situation.
A manager with sellers in another state should read that state's own list, because this article quotes Washington's list and the federal text.
How jobs are compared: responsibility and working conditions
The California material gives two working definitions. According to California Department of Industrial Relations, responsibility refers to the degree of accountability required in performing the job, with emphasis on the importance of the job.
Working conditions, according to California Department of Industrial Relations, refers to surroundings and hazards.
These are California definitions, offered here as vocabulary rather than as a Washington rule. A sales manager in another state should check that state's job-comparison terms with the people who advise the company.
A manager can turn these definitions into two prompts for the job-based reason. One prompt asks how much accountability the job carries and how much importance it has. The other asks what surroundings and hazards the job involves.
A short answer to each prompt works well in a note. For responsibility, the answer names how much accountability the role carries and why the role's importance fits the pay being discussed. For working conditions, the answer names the surroundings and hazards the role involves, so the difference is tied to the work itself.
Testing each reason against both prompts keeps the note focused on the job itself rather than on personal details. If a reason cannot be answered with either prompt, the reason is probably about the seller rather than the role, and that gap is worth noticing before the next conversation.
Illustrative example: one seller note
This example is invented for illustration and is not drawn from any source. Two sellers, Seller A and Seller B, work on the same team and sit in one comparison group. Seller A earns 10 more a week than Seller B. The note records the comparison group, the classes checked and the job-based reason. The note then checks that reason against each class on the Washington list before the pay conversation.
Good-faith minimum wage ordinance exception
The last point is an exception rather than a rule of its own. According to Washington State Legislature, a differential in compensation based in good faith on a local government ordinance providing for a minimum wage different from state law does not constitute discrimination under this section.
The exception names one kind of difference, a differential tied to a local minimum wage ordinance.
Before a manager points to a local ordinance as the reason for a seller pay difference, the ordinance and the basis for the difference should be written down and reviewed with the people who advise the company. If the difference does rest on a local ordinance, the note should name that ordinance and explain the link to the pay in plain words.
Each other reason needs its own job-based note. A seller paid differently for a reason outside the local ordinance should have that reason written separately, not folded into the ordinance point.
Source reference at a glance
Publishers and the phrases quoted from their pages:
| Publisher | Source page | Quoted point |
|---|---|---|
| Washington State Legislature | RCW 49.58.020 | "asserting discrimination based on the person's membership in more than one protected class" |
| Washington State Department of Labor and Industries | Equal Pay & Opportunities Act | "Protected classes are defined as: age (40 and older), sex, marital status" |
| California Department of Industrial Relations | California Equal Pay Act | "Responsibility refers to the degree of accountability required in performing the job" |
| U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission | Equal Pay/Compensation Discrimination | "Title VII also makes it illegal to discriminate based on sex in pay and benefits." |
Next step for seller pay notes
Your next step is to check your seller pay notes against the Washington protected class list and record the job-based reason for each pay difference.
The list appears earlier in this article, so each seller entry can be checked against it the next time a pay question comes up. Each entry can hold the comparison group, the classes checked and the job-based reason in one place, so the note is easy to find before a pay conversation.
Related guides: Sales paycheck deductions: 4 steps for pay talks · Sales rep final pay: 7 checks for the payroll handoff.
FAQ: protected classes and pay
Which classes does Washington protect in pay?
Washington's list includes age (40 and older), sex, race and disability, among others, according to Washington State Department of Labor and Industries. The full list appears in the section above.
Can one complaint cite more than one class?
Yes, the statute allows a complaint to rest on more than one protected class, according to Washington State Legislature.
Does Title VII cover pay?
Title VII covers pay on several bases named in its source. According to U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, those bases include race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age and disability.
What is the minimum wage ordinance exception?
It covers one kind of difference: a good-faith differential tied to a local minimum wage ordinance, according to Washington State Legislature.